Comparing Paper Bullion, Jewellery, Coins and Digital Options

Indian households have many ways to own yellow metal, and each has its own personality. Someone researching Gold ETF funds​ may find the choices bewildering, particularly when a relative argues for coins while a colleague checks the SBI gold ETF share price on an app and recommends going electronic. A clear comparison can help you decide which route matches your purpose.

Jewellery: Beauty With a Price Tag

Jewellery can be part of your celebrations, festivals and family identity. There is no better feeling than wearing a piece of jewellery from your grandmother. However, jewellery as an investment can be limited. There can be high making charges from a few % up to over 10%, depending on the design. You will have to pay wastage, stones etc. Then, when it comes to selling you won’t get as much as you paid.

You will have to pay locker rent per year if you store them in a locker. Storing them in your own home could pose a risk. Overall, I would recommend that jewellery is more of a cultural/personal investment.

Coins & Bars

Coins & Bars have lower making charges than jewellery. They are very popular to buy on Dhanteras. It is easier to determine how much they are worth as they are roughly at the going rate plus a small premium. Usually there will be a note showing the purity. Just make sure you buy from a reputable seller.

They do have similar issues to jewellery, just not as severe. You will still have to store them safely and there may be a loss when you sell. If you buy smaller coins there will be higher costs per gram. However, if you like having a physical item, then this is a good halfway point.

Exchange Traded Units

These are units that are listed. This means that they are held in custody and reflect the price domestically. You buy/sell them via a demat account and the prices can be seen during market times. There are no making charges; you don’t have to worry about the purity and don’t have to worry about storing them. The fees will be a small annual expense ratio, brokerage and bid/offer spread.

With these being regulated by SEBI, you can be assured that the fund house will follow certain rules around custody, valuation, and transparency. This is a very simple investment requiring a demat and trading account. You will also have to be willing to monitor the market sometimes. You also won’t be able to wear them, which can be an issue for some.

Mutual Fund Schemes

Some mutual fund schemes hold Exchange Traded Units. These can be purchased with monthly contributions and do not require a demat account. If you like to invest easily by automating your investments these are perfect. However there are additional costs.

Digital Gold can be purchased through payment/shopping apps and has become popular for small amounts. The most appealing aspect is the ease of use. However when investing you should ensure that you understand the regulations around these. They may not be as regulated as Exchange Traded Units. Ensure that you are purchasing from a reputable provider and know how they will store your investment and what the costs are.

Which Investment?

If you are looking to celebrate/give as a gift then jewellery/coins would be a good option. If you are looking to protect your wealth in the long term then usually listed units or fund based schemes would be more efficient. If you want to invest small amounts then digital options could be appealing. However ensure you carry out due diligence. If you want to invest regularly each month then mutual fund contributions or automated brokerage plans would work well.

Many households will use a mix of investments. They will have a small amount of jewellery for celebrations and hold the investment in an electronic format to avoid any unnecessary costs.

Taxation & Documentation

Depending on the type of investment and how long you have held it for there will be different tax implications. Recent union budgets have changed the rules. If you are selling physical items, there may be different documentation required compared to listed units. Ensure you check the current rules by speaking to official guidelines or a chartered accountant. Whatever investment you go for ensure you keep your documents (bills, contract notes, statements) safe. It is important to know when/what price you bought your investment for.

Final Thoughts

There is no one ‘best’ investment, it will depend on what your goals, personality and situation are. Be honest with yourself about the costs, ease, security and sentimental value. Start with a small amount and see how you feel. By carefully mixing traditional and modern investments, you can create a good investment for your family for decades.

Zeen is a next generation WordPress theme. It’s powerful, beautifully designed and comes with everything you need to engage your visitors and increase conversions.